tried sponges?

topic posted Mon, August 16, 2004 - 1:43 PM by  Jaya!
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
anyone tried sea pearls or other sponges? i did once but it was hard to get out. heard you should sew some thread or fishing line in it to remove.

any info?
thanks!
posted by:
Jaya!
SF Bay Area
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: tried sponges?

    Wed, August 18, 2004 - 5:53 PM
    I have used only sponges now for about a year. I have not had the issue of getting the sponge out, just used PC muscles to move it down and then grabbed either side. I have also heard of the string sewn on, but I worry about the sponge tearing especially as it gets older.
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: tried sponges?

      Wed, August 25, 2004 - 3:18 PM
      I may have missed a previous discusion about sponges since I just recently became a part of this tribe. But could some one possibly tell me what are some of the various uses for these particular sponges your speaking of.
      • Re: tried sponges?

        Wed, August 25, 2004 - 4:10 PM
        an alternative to tampons.
        • tried sponges?

          Wed, August 25, 2004 - 8:25 PM
          sea sponge it's is an natural non-toxic alternative it is long lasting and safe though as you can tell if your pc muscles are not up to snuff many be tricky to remove

          the benifits of having stronge and aware pc muscle are invaluable
          • Unsu...
             

            Re: tried sponges?

            Wed, August 25, 2004 - 11:39 PM
            Thanks for answering my question. It sounds like a good alternative to what is found in the mainstream markets. I may have to give them a try.
            • Re: tried sponges?

              Sun, August 29, 2004 - 10:30 AM
              i joined to post this (actually i followed you here tristan, hope you don't mind)

              i love sea sponges! i found that sewing floss through the sponge in kind of a red-ribbony pattern, plus being mindful and not just yanking it out, hasn't taken any of the life out of my sponges. i still replace them sometimes, but not as often as a box of bleached tampons! yuck.
              • Unsu...
                 

                Re: tried sponges?

                Sun, August 29, 2004 - 3:53 PM
                Hi Val,

                Don't mind at all that you followed me. It shows that we have a couple of things in common. I do have a question; you mentioned sewing floss through the sponge. What kind of floss?

                Yes the bleached tampons are yuck. And I beleive that too many things that are consumed have way too much chemical treatments addeded.

                I have been trying to make it a point to know exactly what I am putting into my body...be it inserted such as a tampon or the food that I am eating.

                Thanks for the information.

                Tristan
                • Re: tried sponges?

                  Mon, August 30, 2004 - 6:23 AM
                  i just use dental floss.
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: tried sponges?

                    Thu, December 16, 2004 - 5:38 PM
                    What about a risk of toxic shock?

                    I used to work in a fish store -we grew bacteria in sponges. Natural or not, I don't think putting a sponge in your vagina sounds safe. It would harbor bacteria, and if peices broke off in your vagina (even tiny ones) it would give bacteria a very good hold.

                    my.webmd.com/content/art...7/1840_50772
                    • Re: tried sponges?

                      Sun, December 19, 2004 - 2:35 PM
                      Sponges can cause problems, yes. But so can Tampons which leave microscopic pieces of cotton inside. So can pads. But what can we do? We need something! I am past menopause but did use sponges and never had a problem. When you rinse it out to remove the blood, use soap, rinse thoroughly!!! After your period, a good soak iin rubbing alcohol kills any germs, then just dry it out completely, keep it in a ziplock bag to keep germs out. I also still washed it with antibacterial hand soap prior to using it the next month because I guess I was paranoid. Never in 5 years of use did I have a problem. Oh, and when you are done with your period, a single douch with just vinegar and water gets out any leftover particles. Or even just plain water!

                      I know people who get toxic shock because they don't change their tampax for 2 or 3 days, especially the light days of their period. Hello!!!! What part of rotten blood do you not understand? Treat it like you treat your cooking and handling of chicken and fish.....clean, clean, clean, and while we cannot refrigerate (smile) we can dispose of it several times a day. Right?
                      • Re: tried sponges?

                        Mon, December 20, 2004 - 8:38 AM
                        Thanks, Charlotte. Good practical advice. I think sponges are a good idea but if people aren't vigilant (like you were) the risk of infection sounds pretty high.

                        I don't think you were paranoid. We have to be very careful!
                        • Re: tried sponges?

                          Sun, January 16, 2005 - 2:27 PM
                          I use the keeper for the heavy days, and homemade flannel pads the whole time. I find my body doesn't like the keeper in for more than two or three days at a time (i start to get sore, i may be allergic to rubber). It doesn't leave anything inside tho.
                          • silicon cups?

                            Tue, January 25, 2005 - 11:08 AM
                            my friend told me that there are these new silicon cups that you can pop in there and just empty... something like a cervical cap/diaphram type thingie...

                            anyone know anything more about those?

                            sponges sound a little too "ewwy" for me... as with re-usable pads.
                            • Re: silicon cups?

                              Tue, April 26, 2005 - 8:27 AM
                              You can buy these in regular stores, i think they're called "instead"... of course, they're marketed to use one time & dispose....
                              • Re: silicon cups?

                                Wed, May 4, 2005 - 8:52 AM
                                there is "the keeper" made from rubber and "the diva cup" is the same product made frm silicon. i strongly suggest getting either of these products, in canada you can only get the diva cup. or buy online!

                                i have been using the keeper since grade 10 and it never lets me down. its easy to clean, u just use soap and between cycles you can soak it in vinegar if u want. chance of infection is low, no TSS possibilities. sometimes bacteria can grow in pools of blood (cuz it holds yr blood like a cup) but c'mon, just don't leave it in longer than 10 hrs and yr fine. plus it saves you so much money as they last up to 10 years. i use homemade cloth pads at nite sometimes too.
                          • Re: tried sponges?

                            Thu, July 7, 2005 - 11:23 AM
                            i have been using the Keeper for about 4 years. I still have the only one i bought (no replacement needed!), it doesn't leak, and i find it amazingly comfortable - i cannot even feel it. i wear it for my entire cycle with no problems.
                            • Re: tried sponges?

                              Tue, March 14, 2006 - 4:02 PM
                              old thread I know but I had to chime in. I used to use sponges but my issue was one they are full they are FULL! I use the Diva cup now and really like it. I like being able to measure my flow and even use it for gardening. Your blood is full of nutrients! Also wanted to let ya'll know there is a tribe that celebrates our moons-The Red Tent. have a good one all!
  • Re: tried sponges?

    Mon, June 19, 2006 - 1:42 PM
    Can anyone provide a link for the silicon version of the menstrual cup? Latex allergies have kept me from exploring this option, although I have used the sponge with no problems (provided, of course, I was careful to rinse out with water and squeeze every couple of hours when the flow was heaviest and clean with vinegar every night to kill bacteria). This option would work much better for long travel, work, etc. Has anyone tried the cup for swimming?
  • Re: tried sponges?

    Tue, February 20, 2007 - 7:30 AM
    I have used them for about three years now and I love them. Mine came with a little piece of thread already sewn on so I would go for it although I would suggest a cotton twine or something like that, fishing line might be uncomfortable
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: tried sponges?

      Mon, May 21, 2007 - 9:21 AM
      A lady in a public bathroom one time saw my friend washing out her sponge in the sink. They closed up the bathroom and sanitized the WHOLE room. Kinda funny....
      • Re: tried sponges?

        Thu, May 24, 2007 - 12:28 PM
        While the restroom attendants' reaction may seem a little backward and wildly out-of-proportion to most of us, they were most likely "sanitizing" the restroom because they have been trained to treat all bodily fluids--sputum, vomit, urine, feces, breastmilk, semen, etc., but especially blood--with extreme caution because of the high potential for the spread of blood-borne pathogens such as the HIV virus and hepatitis. Granted, your friend was most likely not infected with anything, and had done a conscientiously thorough job of rinsing the blood down the drain, cleaning the sink with the antibacterial soap provided, and mopping up any splashes that might have occured, but sanitation personnel (as well as health care workers and others who work in a capacity that regularly exposes them to bodily fluid) are trained to treat ALL bodily fluids as potentially infectious because there is no way to know for sure whether an individual is infected, or not.

        That explanation aside, as a trained healthcare worker (I did massage therapy in the San Francisco Bay Area, where the threat of AIDS was very real, and worked in gynecology, dealing regularly with vaginal fluids like menstrual blood) and an elementary school employee, I believe that the restroom attendants may have gone overboard in shutting down the place and "sanitizing" the whole room. True, if alerted to the situation, I would have investigated, probably sprayed the offending sink down and donned gloves to wipe it thoroughly, and (if there had been any evidence of further "contamination") mopped the immediate area, but I doubt it was necessary to go beyond that. I imagine your friend felt a little stigmatized and embarassed by their overblown reaction to her innocent act. Between our early conditioning to fear germs and our very real need to exercise Universal Precautions (gloving, using a hypochloric (1:10 solution of bleach and water) spray to clean surfaces with, etc.) we are a culture that has become outlandishly squeamish and paranoid about things which are generally very natural bodily functions. I have met many people who refuse to clean up their own vomit, been in a relationship with a man who recoiled at the thought of touching his own semen, and been berated by a stranger for breastfeeding my infant daughter (in a private alcove with a blanket covering us), who told me it was "disgusting" and that I belonged in the bathroom. We go to exaggerated lengths to avoid touching our own excretions, and there are many industries which capitalize on this fact by inventing even more ways. It is truly ironic that, as our attention to staying clean and to killing germs through substances like antibiotics and vaccines and the widely-available antibacterial soaps designed for every conceivable need--dishwashing, housecleaning, handwashing, etc.--we find that our children are growing up much more vulnerable to microbial infection than ever before.
  • Re: tried sponges?

    Tue, July 3, 2007 - 7:28 PM
    i didn't see this mentioned yet, but i may have missed it. Lunapads

    www.lunapads.com/

    cloth reusable pads. and there's no reason they can't be home made instead of purchased. how do you think women handled this before pads & tampons were invented? my grandmother told me that when she was young, girls who were menstruating were not allowed to be in school for that week. they had to stay home in bed & miss an entire week of school every month. it was the schools rule. (this was way out in rural TN in the 30's) so her & her sisters all sewed their own pads that were washed & reused.
    • Re: tried sponges?

      Fri, July 6, 2007 - 2:34 PM
      Yes, women of the past (and many women today) relied on reusable cloth during their cycles. There are many brands of reusable pads out there, in many sizes, shapes (with "wings" or without), thickness (from the thinner pads to be used in place of panti-liners for days when your flow is light, to much thicker, wider, and longer pads to be used during the post-partum period), fabrics (flannels, knits, bird's-eye (the fabric they make cloth diapers from), organic cotton, hemp, etc.), and colors. My circle of friends in the Bay Area used them extensively, and we even circulated a pattern one of the ladies had taken from a set of pads she had bought, since the intial cost of transitioning over to cloth can be prohibitively expensive ($60 plus for a "starter kit"). They are pretty simple to make. A simple Google search (with search terms: "free sewing pattern reusable menstrual pad") turned up literally thousands of sites with information on how to design and sew your own. One of the first results was www.clothpads.org, which not only had a directory full of helpful sites, but also included informational articles and resources.

      The pads can easily be washed in your washing machine, but there are a few things to keep in mind. Chlorine bleach is not recommended, so don't count on white pads staying perfect, pristine white. Fabric softener is also not recommended, because it coats the fibers of the fabric and makes it less absorbant.
      • Re: tried sponges?

        Mon, October 1, 2007 - 10:33 PM
        I was told by my acupuncturist that I should not wear tampons, for a reason that has nothing to do with the fact that they are bleached, or whatever. I had always worn tampons from the time I first started my period and had never even worn a pad before. I had never even experienced what it was like to feel the blood flow. The acupuncturist explained to me that the chi is blocked when you wear a tampon and that pads are much better for the energy flow. It is important not to stop this flow, back it up in anway or it can cause cramping and other symptoms women often feel with their period. I never get cramps since I switched to pads and I enjoy the experience and acceptance of my body as it goes through the menstrual cycle. I have powerful moments of insight, and a surge of consciousness often accompanies these cycles. I consider it a sacred time for myself.
        • Re: tried sponges?

          Fri, June 27, 2008 - 3:09 PM
          That's beautiful Sierra! I definatly feel the difference between the two. sometimes pads are not feasible for me though. I try to use them at the beginning as my cramps are worse then and it does help quite a bit.
  • Re: tried sponges?

    Sat, July 12, 2008 - 4:51 PM
    I have tried the Sea Pearl variety of sponges (got 4 to work with), and not only do they not hold much in them (changing every hour is not cool), they wore out much faster than their average figures, making it more expensive. However, I did mix witch hazel with peroxide and a bit of tea tree oil when cleaning them - did this every time. Maybe that is not the right way to do it - not sure. However, I had no trouble pulling them out, no strings needed for me.
    • Re: tried sponges?

      Thu, January 22, 2009 - 2:40 PM
      I realize this is an old thread, but I have recently found other interesting stuff hehe! One of the things I didn't like about sponges for me (and I forgot to mention it before) was that I bled through so much quicker, which was frustrating. I decided to look into other means and found a plethora of information here!

      www.clothpads.org

      WOW!! I even checked into the alternatives and (as a crocheter) was intrigued by the tampon threads on Craftster! So, I am again looking for alternatives to filling our landfills hehe! I hope this helps othere here too!

Recent topics in "Homespun Consciousness"